Table of contents

The best Bonfire alternatives give nonprofits, schools, creators, and independent artists more control over what they sell, how fast orders ship, and whose brand appears on the package. Printful covers always-on stores with in-house production. Custom Ink Fundraising handles one-off campaigns, Merchloop runs branded spirit and swag stores, and Fourthwall and Spreadshop serve creators.

Bonfire made campaign-style t-shirt fundraising popular, and many organizations start there. As a cause or brand grows, a batch deadline and a page on another company's site start to limit it. This article puts alternatives to Bonfire side by side, comparing sites and platforms on fees, payouts, and fulfillment, verified on each platform's own pages in November 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Bonfire costs nothing to launch, charges an 8% processing fee on extra donations (3.5% for verified nonprofits), and delivers domestic batch orders 7-14 business days after a campaign ends.

  • Custom Ink Fundraising runs the most similar campaign model, with a 2.9% donation fee and a print minimum each page must reach.

  • Printful prints 607 products on demand, connects to Shopify, Squarespace, and other platforms, and offers free Quick Stores for US sellers.

  • Schools, teams, and individual creators who need gear for a single event date can save up to 55% on Printful bulk orders of over 25 items.

  • Fourthwall and Spreadshop give creators free branded shops, and Merchloop builds always-open stores for organizations.

Printful logo
man with jacket
Printful logo
Run your next merch fundraiser on Printful, free to start
Get started

How Bonfire works, and where it falls short

Bonfire lets individuals and organizations design custom apparel and sell it through a campaign page or a free online store. Organizers customize one of thousands of design templates or upload artwork, set prices, and share the campaign with supporters. Bonfire doesn't charge sellers to launch and handles payment processing, printing, shipping, and customer service.

Its nonprofit tools explain its popularity with causes. Supporters can add donations at checkout, subject to an 8% processing fee, and verified nonprofits pay 3.5%. Verified organizations also receive peer-to-peer fundraisers and supporter contact exports, and Bonfire reports that more than 18,000 nonprofits are on the platform.

The problems start with timing. Batch campaigns collect orders for 2-21 days, and domestic orders arrive 7-14 business days after the batch ends. Bonfire's Print on Demand mode prints orders the next business day, but the base cost resets to its maximum each day, which lowers profit per item.

Brand control sets the second limit. Campaigns and Bonfire stores live on bonfire.com, and Bonfire's published integrations cover YouTube Merch Shelf, Linktree, and fundraising platforms such as GoFundMe. Organizations that want to manage merch on their own site choose other platforms.

Campaign-based fundraising vs an always-on merch store

Campaigns collect orders for a set period and print them in a batch. An always-on store prints each order as it arrives and keeps selling until the organization removes the products.

When a time-limited campaign makes sense

Campaigns fit one-time causes and event dates, such as race-day shirts, a memorial fund, or a single team season. A deadline gives supporters a reason to order now, and on Bonfire, a larger batch lowers the cost per item.

When an ongoing store raises more

An ongoing store fits organizations with a lasting community. Alumni, parents, and fans buy at different times of the year, and new designs each season reach the same supporters without a new campaign – benefits that add up over time. Print on Demand gives this model its staying power by removing inventory risk. Printful makes each product after a supporter orders it, with no order minimums. It has shipped more than 149704159 items since 2013.

Bonfire alternatives for nonprofits and causes

Nonprofits comparing the best Bonfire alternatives weigh donation handling, brand control, and the work volunteers take on.

1. Printful with Shopify or Squarespace

Printful gives nonprofits an always-on store on their own website. Organizations connect Printful to Shopify, Squarespace, WooCommerce, Wix, Etsy, and other platforms and sell from a Catalog of 607 products across categories from apparel and hoodies to accessories and home decor. The model fits nonprofits that already run a website.

Pros

  • In-house production, backed by more than a decade of experience, includes a three-step quality check, and 99.76% of orders meet or exceed customer expectations.

  • Reshipment rates stay low.

  • Fulfillment takes 2-5 business days for most orders.

  • White-label packaging ships under the organization's brand, and pack-ins such as stickers or thank-you cards enhance the delivery for supporters.

Cons

  • Printful has no built-in donation tool, so organizations take donations through their site or a separate platform.

  • On Squarespace, the Printful integration requires a plan with selling enabled: Business, Commerce Basic, or Commerce Advanced.

2. Custom Ink

Custom Ink Fundraising gives organizers a free fundraising page where supporters buy custom apparel, add a donation, or donate without buying. Its one-time group order model works much like Bonfire's.

Pros

  • Donations incur a  2.9% processing fee, which is lower than Bonfire's 8%.

  • Bulk shipping to a single address costs nothing and includes a guaranteed delivery date.

  • Custom Ink runs its own Design Lab, and its designers provide expert help.

Cons

  • Each page has a print minimum. If a page misses the deadline, Custom Ink refunds supporters and prints nothing, but if donations total at least $20, they still reach the cause.

  • Orders arrive about 12 working days after the campaign closes.

3. Merchloop

Merchloop builds on-demand branded stores for organizations. Stoked On Printing launched it in 2018, and it fits nonprofits that need an always-open store for staff, volunteers, and donors.

Pros

  • The free Merchloop Lite tier charges no startup, monthly, or annual fees.

  • Nonprofits can keep a margin on each item supporters buy.

  • The catalog includes premium brands such as Nike, The North Face, and YETI.

Cons

  • Merchloop's own nonprofit guide notes that the platform isn't designed for public fundraising campaigns where supporters buy merch to donate proceeds.

  • Merchloop doesn't advertise a blanket nonprofit discount.

Bonfire alternatives for schools, teams, and clubs

Schools, teams, and clubs need gear for a single date, such as a tournament, and spirit wear that families buy year-round. Alternatives to Bonfire handle each need differently.

Bulk orders vs on-demand fulfillment

Bulk orders make an ideal fit for a fixed date and a known head count. Printful's fundraising program cuts prices by up to 55% on orders of 25 or more items of the same base product, with sizes, colors, and designs mixed in one order. Custom Ink's free bulk shipping, covered above, adds a guaranteed delivery date to a group order.

On-demand fulfillment fits spirit wear. Each family orders its own size, and Printful ships directly to them, so the school carries no risk of unsold stock.

Best options for spirit wear and team gear

For a year-round spirit store, Printful's Quick Stores offer a free storefront that takes minutes to set up, currently for US sellers and US shipping addresses only. Embroidery on caps, beanies, and hoodies gives team gear a stitched logo. Because Printful handles printing and shipping, maintaining the store stays within reach of a volunteer team.

Custom Ink is a good choice for a one-team order with a deadline, and Merchloop is a great fit for a managed spirit store stocked with premium brands.

Bonfire alternatives for creators and small brands

Individual creators, independent artists, and small brands sell to an existing audience, so store features and branding matter most. Marketplaces such as Redbubble let shoppers discover independent artists through marketplace search, which also means competition with thousands of similar designs. Redbubble charges a platform fee of up to 50% of monthly earnings on Standard accounts. The three sites like Bonfire below keep the brand with the creator.

4. Fourthwall

Fourthwall combines a branded website, print-on-demand merch, memberships, and digital products into a single platform, used by more than 500,000 individual creators and companies. Its other features center on creator monetization.

Pros

  • Fourthwall costs nothing to start.

  • Donations and tips incur only a 2.9% + $0.30 card processing fee per US transaction.

  • Creators can leverage YouTube Merch Shelf, Instagram and Facebook Shopping, and TikTok Shopping to sell where fans already watch.

Cons

  • Memberships carry a 5% fee on every plan.

  • The free plan caps teams at two members, which limits volunteer-run groups.

5. Spreadshop

Spreadshop gives creators a free shop with hundreds of products. Each base price covers the item with one print included, and the seller adds a margin on top – Spreadshop's own example shows a $12 base price and $11 profit.

Pros

  • Among free Bonfire alternatives, Spreadshop is a good fit for creators who want a shop without running a website.

  • Spreadshop handles printing, shipping, and customer service, and 95% of orders are ready to ship within 48 hours.

Cons

  • Spreadshop sets every base price, so sellers control earnings only through their margin.

6. Printful Quick Stores

Printful Quick Stores are also a good alternative here. Creators create a simple storefront on the same Printful Catalog, an easy start for anyone without a website.

Pros

  • Setup needs no code, and the store has no monthly fee.

  • Printful handles fulfillment and customer service and takes the shipping hassle off creators.

  • Brands that outgrow Quick Stores connect Printful to Shopify or Etsy and keep the same products.

Cons

  • Quick Stores currently serves US sellers and US shipping addresses only.

  • Payouts arrive monthly, once earnings reach $25.

How fundraising payouts compare across sites like Bonfire

It's essential to understand how much money reaches the cause, and when, before promising funds. Three questions separate websites like Bonfire.

Who sets the price and the profit per item

On Bonfire, Printful, Spreadshop, and Spring (formerly Teespring), sellers set the retail price, and profit equals the retail price minus the base cost. Spring's own example shows a $10 base tee sold for $24, with a $14 profit. On Bonfire, the base cost falls as more items sell in a batch.

How donations and proceeds reach the cause

Bonfire, Custom Ink, and Fourthwall accept donations alongside merch. On Printful and Spreadshop, organizations transfer merch profits to the cause and collect donations separately.

Fees, base costs, and payout timing

Donation fees range from card processing only on Fourthwall to 2.9% on Custom Ink and 8% on Bonfire. On Printful, timing depends on the store type. With Shopify or Squarespace, supporters pay the organization at checkout, and Printful charges only for fulfillment and shipping. With Quick Stores, supporters pay Printful at checkout, and Printful sends monthly payouts through Stripe once earnings reach $25.

How to run a merch fundraiser without Bonfire

The steps in this section use Printful, and the same process works on most Bonfire alternatives in this guide.

  1. Create a free Printful account. Sign up for a free Printful account. Access to all Printful tools costs nothing.

  2. Pick products supporters want. Browse the Printful Catalog. T-shirts and hoodies cover most fundraiser orders, and accessories such as hats and tote bags offer variety. Choose durable apparel supporters will wear after the event – a quick poll can turn guesses into product ideas.

  3. Design your products. Bring your designs to life in the free Design Maker, then order samples to check print quality, fit, and color before you sell.

  4. Open your store. Launch a free Quick Store (US only) or connect Printful to Shopify, Squarespace, another platform, or a marketplace like Etsy or eBay.

  5. Set a goal and a deadline. Divide the dollar goal by the profit per item. With $14 profit per shirt, a $1,400 goal takes 100 shirts. Announce a sales window for urgency, and keep the store open for late orders.

  6. Promote your fundraiser to your community. Share the store link where people already pay attention: social posts, newsletters, group chats, and events. Post photos of volunteers or players wearing the merch, update supporters at each milestone, and push one final reminder in the last week.

  7. Send profits to your cause. Transfer the agreed share once payouts arrive, and link the store to a donation page for supporters who want to give more.

Tip: Learn how to sell merch to fundraise for a nonprofit with Printful Quick Stores.

Launch your fundraiser store with Printful

Among websites like Bonfire, the right fit depends on how long you plan to sell. Custom Ink suits a single campaign, Fourthwall and Spreadshop suit creators, and Printful suits nonprofits, schools, and brands that want an always-on store with in-house quality control and room to grow.

Printful logo
man with jacket
Printful logo
Open your free Printful store and start raising funds
Start selling

FAQ

Yes, several free Bonfire alternatives exist. Printful Quick Stores, Custom Ink Fundraising, Fourthwall, Spreadshop, and Merchloop Lite all cost nothing to launch. Each platform earns from product base costs or processing fees instead. Printful Quick Stores currently serves US sellers and shoppers only, and Printful's integrations work with paid store builders such as Shopify.

Custom Ink charges a lower donation fee, at 2.9%, compared to Bonfire's 8%. Custom Ink requires each page to meet a print minimum; otherwise, nothing prints. Bonfire has no print minimum and offers a 3.5% donation fee reduction and peer-to-peer tools for verified nonprofits. Both ship campaign orders after the campaign ends.

Yes, nonprofits can sell merch through Printful via a free Quick Store or a connected Shopify, Squarespace, or WooCommerce store. Printful prints each item after a supporter orders, with no minimums. Quick Stores currently serve US sellers, and US addresses only. Printful has no donation tool, so nonprofits collect donations separately.

A t-shirt fundraiser increases profit by multiplying the profit per shirt by the number sold. At $14 profit per shirt, 100 shirts raise $1,400, and 500 shirts raise $7,000. Profit per shirt depends on the retail price and base cost, and donations added at checkout increase the total on platforms that accept them.

Chan Robbertse

By Chan Robbertse

Chan is a copywriter, creative writer, and technical writer with 15 years of experience creating everything from training courses to compelling marketing copy. A self-confessed research nerd, she loves digging deep into a subject and bringing it to life on the page. When she’s not writing, she’s exploring forest trails or walking the beach with her dog, or in the kitchen experimenting with homemade pickles and jams.