Table of contents

Threadless alternatives are worth a look once your merch shop outgrows Artist Shops. Threadless makes launching a merch shop easy, but you might want a custom domain, embroidered products, membership perks, or a different way to reach buyers.

Below, we compare nine options for creators and artists – covering storefronts, fees, fulfillment, and what changes when you move from a marketplace to building your own business.

Threadless Artist Shops at a glance

Threadless combines hosted Artist Shops with a separate built-in marketplace. You create the artwork and choose products, and Threadless handles production and delivery.

An Artist Shop gives you a free, personalized storefront with your branding and product collections. Set your own prices, or let Threadless manage pricing and promotions with Managed Pricing.

The earnings model depends on where the sale happens:

  • Artist Shop: You earn the net retail price minus the base fee. The base fee covers the product cost plus a 5% processing fee on the net retail price.

  • Threadless Marketplace: You earn 10% of the net retail price.

Net retail price is what the customer pays, minus VAT and any licensing fees. So the same product can earn you very different amounts depending on where it sells.

Threadless also lets you export customer order information and send branded marketing emails to grow your customer base and encourage repeat sales.

Before switching, pin down what your next platform needs to add: a different shopping experience, more products, new marketing tools, or better profit margins.

What to look for in a Threadless alternative

Before comparing sites like Threadless, write down what your current shop stops you from doing. “I want to sell embroidered hats with my logo” leads to a clearer shortlist than “I want something better.”

Storefront design and custom domains

Threadless shops live on a personalized address ending in .threadless.com, and checkout happens on your Artist Shop page.

If you want to sell merch at shop.yourbrand.com, look for native custom domain support. Then check whether you can adjust navigation, create collection pages, and show merch alongside your other work.

A custom domain doesn’t give you full control over the website. Some hosted merch platforms support your address but limit page layouts or checkout. List the features you need to express your brand identity – from collection names to the shopping experience – and check each one.

Customer information and email marketing

Threadless already gives you order information, so compare how each platform lets you put it to work. Check what customer data you can access, export, and connect to your email tools, like automatic integrations, purchase-based segments, or a newsletter signup on your own website.

Product costs and take-home profits

Compare the same design on a similar product, shipped to the same destination, on each alternative you’re considering. Include printing, shipping, payment fees, and any subscription costs.

A lower base cost doesn’t automatically mean higher profit margins. What you keep also depends on your selling price, discounts, and the cost of attracting each buyer.

On royalty-based marketplaces, check how promotions affect your artist margin. For your own store, factor in expenses you incur, such as subscriptions and ads. Then compare each pricing structure against your expected sales, not the cheapest advertised product.

Payouts and upfront spending

When you get paid depends on the business model. Marketplaces and hosted shops deduct production costs before paying you. With a fulfillment platform like Printful, customers pay your store, and you pay for production as orders come in.

So even without buying inventory, you might need money set aside to cover orders before your store payout arrives.

List upfront costs like samples, store subscriptions, and ads separately from per-order fulfillment payments. Then check when each platform releases earnings and whether there’s a payout threshold.

9 Alternatives for selling print-on-demand products

These alternatives to Threadless cover three business models:

  • Fulfillment for your own store: Printful

  • Hosted creator shops: Fourthwall, Spreadshop, and Bonfire

  • Print-on-demand marketplaces: Redbubble, TeePublic, Zazzle, Displate, and Fine Art America

1. Printful: Best for building a merch brand across channels

Printful connects product creation and fulfillment to whichever storefront you choose. You pick the products, add your artwork, and decide how to present them. Printful produces and ships each order as it comes in.

This setup suits creators who want merch to be part of a bigger brand, not a side shelf. Start with illustrated t-shirts, add embroidered caps, then introduce framed prints, without buying stock for any of them.

With Printful’s print-on-demand service, you can sell 607 products across apparel, accessories, and home goods.

Key features

  • Store connections: Use Printful integrations with Shopify, TikTok Shop, Etsy, Squarespace, and other supported sales channels.

  • Design tools: Create designs in the free Design Maker and preview them with the Mockup Generator.

  • Custom branding options: Add custom inside labels, branded packing slips, and other touches that make every order feel like your brand.

  • Regional production: Orders are made across 12 Printful and partner facilities, including in-house fulfillment centers in North America and Europe.

Pros

  • Choose your storefront: Sell on your own site, launch Quick Stores, or connect fulfillment to a marketplace shop.

  • Quality checks on every order: A  3-step inspection process covers artwork, production, and final checks.

  • Room to grow: Combine printing and embroidery across print-on-demand products under one brand.

Cons

  • You run the retail side: Promotion, store policies, and buyer communication are your responsibility.

  • No marketplace traffic by default: Unless you sell on a marketplace like Etsy, you bring the visitors.

Pricing

Printful is free to use – there are no monthly fees to create products or connect your store. You pay for the product and shipping when an order comes in.

The optional Growth plan costs $24.99/month and gives you up to 33% off product prices, resulting in higher margins or lower retail prices. It becomes free once you reach $12K in annual sales.

Which store should you connect to?

  • TikTok Shop: Sell on the massive social media platform that millions of people use as a product discovery engine.

  • Shopify: A strong pick when merch is central to your business, and you want room to grow your storefront and marketing setup.

  • Squarespace or Wix: Add merch to an existing portfolio or creator website on a supported eCommerce plan.

  • Etsy: Pair Printful fulfillment with Etsy’s marketplace audience while you manage listings, prices, and buyer messages.

For existing eCommerce stores, this print-on-demand platform lets you add merch without switching to another service. It’s also a strong Redbubble alternative  for artists ready to build a brand around their work.

Printful logo
man with jacket
Printful logo
Start selling t-shirts and more worldwide
Sign up

2. Fourthwall: Best for merch, digital products, and memberships

Fourthwall brings several creator income streams into one hosted shop – physical merch, digital downloads, and paid memberships.

An illustrator could sell prints alongside downloadable brushes, while a video creator could add members-only content. Its storefront and community tools keep those offers in one place. As a Threadless alternative, Fourthwall suits creators who already have an audience and want one home for it.

Key features

  • Custom domains: Connect a branded address to your shop.

  • Multiple product types: Sell physical merch, digital products, and memberships together.

  • Community tools: Offer exclusive content and member perks.

Pros

  • Everything in one place: Fans don’t need separate destinations for every purchase.

  • Free plan: Launch and test before upgrading.

  • Audience-first setup: Build offers around the content and community you already have.

Cons

  • You bring your own traffic: A hosted shop doesn’t come with marketplace discovery.

  • Fees vary by revenue type: Physical products, downloads, and memberships each have their own fees.

Pricing

The free plan has no monthly subscription. For catalog products, Fourthwall deducts a flat per-product fee from the price you set, and payment processing applies (2.9% + $0.30 per US card transaction).

Its pricing structure also includes a 5% fee on digital products on the free plan and a 5% membership fee. The Pro plan ($15/month) removes the digital product fee and adds extras like shop credit and priority support.

3. Spreadshop: Best for a straightforward hosted merch shop

Spreadshop gives you a free hosted merch shop to send fans to – no separate eCommerce subscription needed. Set up your own shop, pick products, and share the link.

Its focus is familiar merch: t-shirts, hoodies, mugs, and accessories. This hosted print-on-demand platform handles production, shipping, and customer service – a good fit for a band, podcast, or creator whose audience already knows what the merch stands for.

Key features

  • Hosted storefront: Build your shop with Spreadshop’s tools.

  • Pricing controls: Set your margin in the Partner Area.

  • Automatic fulfillment: Production begins as soon as an order comes in.

Pros

  • One link for followers: Send fans from every channel to the same place.

  • Less admin: No need to arrange production or delivery.

Cons

  • Promotion is on you: Spreadshop is separate from the Spreadshirt marketplace, so your shop doesn’t get marketplace traffic.

  • Limited customization: Your shop works within Spreadshop’s layouts and tools.

Pricing

Add your earnings on top of each product’s base price using  Spreadshop’s margin settings. Check your promotion settings, too, as discounts affect your payout.

If you’re considering it as a Threadless or Redbubble alternative, plan how you’ll replace marketplace discovery with traffic from your audience.

4. Bonfire: Best for community campaigns and event merch

Bonfire organizes merch by campaign and hosted store. It suits a club, community project, band, or creator with a clear reason for people to support a release.

It’s not just for fundraising – for-profit campaigns let you sell a collection and keep the proceeds. That makes Bonfire a Threadless alternative worth considering when you want to build a release around a specific community or occasion.

Key features

  • Campaign pages: Give each release its own focused page.

  • Hosted stores: Show several collections in one place.

  • Profit estimates: Preview earnings in the design tool before launch.

Pros

  • Free to launch: Campaigns have no setup fee.

  • Price control: Choose what supporters pay.

  • Volume savings: Higher order quantities raise your profit per item.

Cons

  • Needs an existing audience: Campaigns rely on people you can already reach.

  • Timing takes planning: Check production and delivery times before promoting an event deadline.

Pricing

Your campaign earnings are the selling price minus the base cost, which covers manufacturing and printing. Product choice, design, and order quantity all affect that cost.

If you turn on additional contributions (donations on top of a purchase), Bonfire charges an 8% processing fee on those – not on regular merch sales.

5. Redbubble: Best for reaching another marketplace audience

Redbubble is an online marketplace where artists add designs to clothing, stickers, accessories, and home products. Redbubble handles production and support while you create and promote your work.

For a Threadless artist, the main draw is a wider audience. Test which illustrations get attention on phone cases or stickers without opening an independent store. As with other print-on-demand marketplaces, sales depend on shoppers finding and choosing your listings.

Key features

  • Artist storefronts: Group your designs within the marketplace.

  • Adjustable markups: Set your margin on top of production and service costs.

  • Managed fulfillment: Redbubble ships orders to customers worldwide.

Pros

  • No website needed: List designs without building or running a store.

  • Lots of products to sell: Put one design on many items.

  • Built-in traffic: Shoppers can find you through marketplace browsing and search.

Cons

  • Account fees cut deep: Standard accounts give up half their monthly earnings.

  • Little control over the shopping experience: Redbubble owns the storefront and checkout.

Pricing

Redbubble’s account fees take 50% of monthly artist earnings from Standard accounts and 20% from Premium accounts. Pro accounts pay no platform or excess markup fees.

Standard and Premium accounts also pay an excess markup fee: 50% of what you earn above a 20% markup. Account fees are capped at $150 per month. Calculate your expected payout before moving a large catalog.

Read more: Redbubble alternatives: 18 best print-on-demand sites

6. TeePublic: Best for artists who prefer preset earnings

TeePublic takes pricing off your plate. Upload designs, add them to products, and earn a set payout on every sale.

That simplicity suits artists who would rather design than adjust margins. The trade-off: your account level and site-wide sales affect earnings and visibility. For anyone seeking a Threadless alternative with preset payouts, TeePublic is worth a look.

Key features

  • Preset artist earnings: Product type and account level set your payout.

  • Managed orders: TeePublic handles production, delivery, and customer support.

  • Core merch formats: Sell clothing, stickers, mugs, and phone cases.

Pros

  • No pricing decisions: Skip setting a price for every listing.

  • No inventory: Products are made when an order is placed.

  • Marketplace exposure: Eligible accounts show up in on-site search.

Cons

  • Fixed margins: You can’t earn more by raising your price.

  • Restricted search access: Only Artisan accounts qualify for on-site search visibility.

Pricing

Artisan accounts earn  $4 for a regular-price classic t-shirt and $2 when it sells during a discount period. Apprentice earnings differ.

These fixed royalties make it easy to forecast earnings per sale, but they don’t guarantee traffic or sales volume.

7. Zazzle: Best for designs buyers personalize

Zazzle turns your artwork into a starting point that buyers customize. An illustration could become a wedding invitation, a business card, or a gift with someone’s name on it.

That makes it a good fit if your style suits occasions and personalized products. This Threadless alternative works well for designers who want to sell editable templates alongside finished designs.

Key features

  • Editable designs: Let customers add names, dates, and messages to your templates.

  • A broad range of categories: Sell stationery, gifts, clothing, and accessories.

  • Royalty settings: Choose your rate within Zazzle’s range.

Pros

  • Built-in buying occasions: Design around weddings, milestones, or business needs.

  • Marketplace discovery: Reach shoppers searching for customizable items.

  • More mileage from one style: Adapt the same look across many product types.

Cons

  • Customization needs testing: Check that names, dates, and longer text fit correctly.

  • Higher royalties raise the final price: And fees cut into your payout.

Pricing

Set royalties of  5%-50% on most physical products. Zazzle Heart products have a fixed 5% rate.

Royalties set above 10% incur an excess royalty fee of 5% of gross royalties. A marketing fee of 35%-50% of gross royalties may also apply, depending on the product category.

Read more: 10 Best Zazzle alternatives to sell custom products

8. Displate: Best for artists specializing in metal posters

Displate focuses on a single format: metal prints for wall display. It suits detailed illustrations that need more space than a small merch print.

To sell through its artist program, review the current application process before you plan a launch. Consider this specialist Threadless alternative when display pieces are central to your collection.

Key features

  • Specialist format: Build a collection around metal wall art.

  • Artist collections: Group related pieces together.

  • Referral earnings: The Share and Earn program rewards eligible sales from your links.

Pros

  • Clear product identity: Buyers know exactly what they’re getting.

  • Art-focused shoppers: Reach people already looking for display pieces.

  • A new home for your original artwork: Give pieces a display-ready finish.

Cons

  • No apparel: You’ll need another service for clothing.

  • No price control: Displate sets retail prices.

Pricing

Commission rates depend on your agreement with Displate. Once eligible earnings reach the  $50 payout threshold, request payment via PayPal.

Check your agreement for regular and referral sales, and don’t estimate earnings from a promotional “up to” rate alone.

9. Fine Art America: Best for photographers and art-print collections

Fine Art America offers a wide choice of display formats, including canvas, framed prints, acrylic, and metal prints.

It suits artists who want buyers to choose how an image looks in their home – a subtle frame for one buyer, a large canvas for another. The platform also sells merch like phone cases, but its wall art range makes it a strong Threadless alternative for print-focused collections.

Key features

  • Multiple print formats: Offer different materials, sizes, and framing options.

  • Artist-set markups: Choose what to add on top of production costs.

  • Website tools: Eligible accounts can add a shopping cart widget to your own website.

Pros

  • Flexible presentation: Sell each image in several formats.

  • Pricing control: Set your own markup on every product.

  • Free to start: A Standard account costs nothing.

Cons

  • Upload cap for free accounts: Standard accounts can upload up to 25 images – Premium accounts remove the limit.

  • Setup takes time: Check cropping and resolution for each format.

Pricing

Choose a free Standard account or Premium for $30 per year.

Fine Art America sets the production price for each print, and you add your markup on top. Check product-specific rules before expanding beyond prints.

Quick comparison of the best sites

Your shortlist should reflect how you want to run your business. Hosted shops reduce admin, print-on-demand marketplaces offer potential discovery, and your own storefront gives you the most say over the retail experience.

Option Business model Best reason to choose it Main consideration
Printful Fulfillment connected to your store Product range, custom branding, and store integrations You run the retail side
Fourthwall Hosted creator shop Merch, digital products, and memberships together You need an audience
Spreadshop Hosted merch shop Simple setup with managed fulfillment Limited shop customization
Bonfire Campaigns and hosted stores Community merch and fundraising Campaign timing and promotion
Redbubble Marketplace Another audience for existing designs High account fees
TeePublic Marketplace Predictable earnings and managed orders Search eligibility and fixed payouts
Zazzle Customizable-product marketplace Occasion-based and editable designs Royalty fees and template setup
Displate Specialist art marketplace Metal display pieces Application and commission terms
Fine Art America Art marketplace with website tools Print formats and framing choices Free account limits

Creator tools: What changes when you switch?

A new platform should improve something you use regularly. Look beyond the catalog and compare the day-to-day tasks: promoting print-on-demand products, rewarding fans, and turning first-time buyers into repeat customers.

Design challenges and artist communities

Threadless is known for its design challenges and artist community. If feedback and creative participation motivate you, weigh those separately from eCommerce features – a community of talented artists serves a different purpose than a sales tool.

A fulfillment-focused print-on-demand platform like Printful handles production and store connections, so you build community through channels you choose, like an illustration group, Discord server, or newsletter. And you don’t have to leave a community you value – creating and selling don’t need to happen in the same place.

Memberships, bundles, and fan perks

With Fourthwall, paid memberships and exclusive content sit alongside merch – think behind-the-scenes videos, early access, or member-only drops.

For a Shopify store connected to Printful, memberships and bundles come from Shopify features or third-party apps, so check how each app passes items to fulfillment.

Email marketing and repeat purchases

Threadless already offers managed email marketing, so a move should improve your workflow, not just recreate it.

If you switch to an independent store, connect an email tool that segments your customer base by purchases or interests – for example, sending a new poster collection only to subscribers who bought your illustration work. Track which messages drive visits and sales, so future promotions build on what works.

Which option is right for you?

The best sites for an artist testing a few designs won’t necessarily suit an established creator with a website and repeat buyers. Choose based on your next business goal and how much work you want to take on.

For new sellers with a small audience

Spreadshop gives you a hosted shop with no subscription. TeePublic suits sellers happy with preset earnings, as long as they understand its search restrictions.

If your priority is learning how to sell under your own brand, start with a small Printful collection. Budget for samples and the storefront, then test demand before expanding. You don’t need a big catalog to start selling – a few well-presented products show you what buyers want.

For building a recognizable merch brand

Choose Printful with a compatible eCommerce storefront when product choice, store presentation, and custom branding are part of your plan.

Connect your own storefront through 22 supported integrations. Your store controls the retail experience, while Printful handles production and shipping. This gives you more control over how the business grows. Add new products, test more sales channels, and sell merch alongside what you already offer.

For content creators and streamers

Put Fourthwall on your shortlist if you want to sell merch and paid community perks together. Spreadshop is a simpler merch destination, and Bonfire suits a release tied to an event, project, or community goal.

Match the offer to your customer base. A channel catchphrase might sell well on t-shirts, while an art tutorial audience might also buy digital resources.

Switching from Threadless: What to plan for

You don’t need to move every design at once. Test your new setup with a focused collection, and keep what already works.

1. Review your artwork rights

Under Threadless’s non-exclusive artwork arrangement, you generally keep the right to use your designs elsewhere.

Check any separate agreements, though. Threadless’s Earn More program includes optional exclusivity, and licensed pop-culture designs may carry additional restrictions. Confirm those terms before you sell the work on other websites.

2. Choose products

Start with designs that already get attention, then pick matching products on your new platform. Browse Printful’s Catalog for high-quality blanks across apparel, accessories, and home decor.

Don’t assume every product, color, or print placement will match your old shop. Compare measurements, materials, and print templates before recreating listings.

If you’re entering a new market, check delivery options and the total price buyers will see. Build your first product range around items you can present and deliver with confidence.

3. Order samples and photograph them

Upload designs using your original source files, then order samples to check print quality and sizing. Wash them following the care instructions to see how they hold up.

Take product photos that show what a mockup can’t: fabric texture, print scale, and how the item looks in use. If you sell t-shirts, show the fit and print clearly – it helps buyers choose the right item and gives your launch real substance.

4. Recalculate your earnings

Build a simple spreadsheet with each product’s base cost, shipping, transaction fees, discounts, and planned price. Planning to sell on Etsy? Use Printful’s Etsy calculator.

Look for more competitive pricing across the whole order, not just the product. A cheaper shirt won’t save money if shipping cancels out the difference.

Compare like-for-like products before changing your prices. Fabric, print method, and delivery destination all affect the result. Then estimate how many sales you need to cover recurring costs before paying for extra tools.

5. Test checkout and fulfillment

Place a test order through your new store. Confirm the right product variant reaches production and that notifications and delivery details make sense.

With Printful, check each product’s connection in your Dashboard and make sure every size and color you offer is synced.

If you plan to continue selling on Threadless too, keep your links and records separate. Track sales by channel to compare earnings and the time each shop takes.

6. Launch to an audience you can reach

Update your website, social profiles, and video descriptions. Tell subscribers what’s new and why you chose these products.

If you rely on organic traffic, create collection pages and write product descriptions around what shoppers actually search for: the design’s subject, the product type, and how it’s used.

Every shop needs a promotion plan, even on platforms with built-in traffic. Pick a few channels you can keep up with, and track which ones drive sales.

Printful logo
man with jacket
Printful logo
Switch to Printful today – your brand deserves it
Make the switch

Grow your merch brand with Printful

When you’re ready to build a brand that lives beyond one platform, Printful gives you a broad product range, store connections, and custom branding to grow it. Our fulfillment service handles production and shipping as orders come in, and you don’t need inventory to start a print-on-demand business around your work.

Start with a product you’re confident in, test it, and build from there. Create your free Printful account, prepare your first collection, and sell products you’re proud to put your name on.

Frequently asked questions

Spreadshop is the closest match, with a similar hosted setup that includes product creation, fulfillment, and customer service. Fourthwall adds digital products and memberships.

 

If you want more flexibility with your website, products, and tools, Printful integrates fulfillment with the storefront of your choice.

Generally, yes. Threadless’s standard arrangement is non-exclusive, so you can continue selling original designs on other platforms. Check any separate exclusivity, licensing, or partnership agreements first.

 

Running both shops lets you test a new platform and compare sales without pulling listings that already sell.

Partly. Print on Demand removes the need to manufacture products and ship each parcel yourself, giving real potential for passive income.

 

The ongoing work depends on your setup. Marketplaces handle more of each transaction, while an independent online store needs customer communication, promotion, and maintenance.

 

Plan around the work you’ll actually do. Choose a platform that frees up time for the parts of the business you want to develop, whether that’s designing, building an audience, or finding new ways to sell your work.

Yes, several do. Spreadshop, Fourthwall, and Bonfire offer free options for hosted shops or campaigns, though product costs and fees still affect your earnings.

 

Printful is free to use, while a connected eCommerce platform may charge separately. Printful’s free Quick Stores let you launch without paying anything. Compare all upfront costs and per-order expenses before choosing where to sell.

Yes, it’s beginner-friendly. Threadless gives you a hosted shop, fulfillment, and the option to set your own prices or use Managed Pricing. It removes many setup tasks, but attracting buyers still takes work.

 

Review the products, earnings, and storefront limits before deciding whether the platform fits the business you want to build.

It depends on how you want to sell. Threadless Artist Shops suit creators who want a dedicated shop with pricing and email tools. Redbubble offers another shopping marketplace, but account fees can take up to half your monthly earnings.

 

Compare expected payouts, products, and how you’ll attract buyers – neither guarantees better sales for every artist.

No single site is the most profitable for everyone. The money you make depends on product costs, fees, prices, discounts, and the cost to win each customer. Compare your expected margin on a specific product and destination.

 

Printful gives you full pricing flexibility through your connected store, while marketplaces apply their own royalty or fee rules.

Zane Bratuskina

By Zane Bratuskina

Zane is a sharp-witted writer with a deep interest in eCommerce, branding, and creative entrepreneurship. With a knack for blending humor, insight, and no-nonsense advice, she crafts engaging content that helps merchants learn and businesses grow. When she’s not dissecting industry trends, she's exploring philosophy, music, and the perfect balance between solitude and connection.